+353-1-416-8900REST OF WORLD
+44-20-3973-8888REST OF WORLD
1-917-300-0470EAST COAST U.S
1-800-526-8630U.S. (TOLL FREE)

Prospects for Online BNPL in Canada, 2024

  • PDF Icon

    Report

  • 70 Pages
  • June 2024
  • Region: Canada
  • Technology Strategies International
  • ID: 5973665

Canadian Online BNPL Expenditure Exceeds $12 Billion in 2023

The global market for BNPL services has grown rapidly over the past five years, spurred on in part by the strong growth in e-commerce during the pandemic years. In 2023, Gross Merchandise Value using BNPL services exceeded $300 billion (USD) worldwide, up from $128.6 billion (USD) in 2019.

In 2023, Canada’s online BNPL expenditure represented 4.1% of global online BNPL expenditure, or $12.3 billion (CAD) in GMV. While Canada was late in the adoption of online BNPL services, growth in GMV since 2019 has outpaced that in all of the more developed jurisdictions.

Almost one third of adult Canadians have used online BNPL services for their e-commerce purchases in the past year, indicating that while online BNPL is gaining traction rapidly in Canada, there is still significant headroom for growth. In 2028, the analyst expects 19.4 million adult Canadians to make use of online BNPL services, with GMV almost quadrupling over the forecast horizon.

Growth in the market is being driven by increasing adoption, higher frequency of use, and higher average order values. This is being stimulated by intense competition, especially between fintech BNPL service providers and traditional credit BNPL providers, with product innovation playing a major role in the battle for both consumers and merchants.

Additional highlights from the study are:

  • Millennials account for the largest share of online BNPL expenditure in Canada
  • Electronics dominates online BNPL expenditure by category, while Clothing, Footwear and Accessories has the highest proportion of BNPL users making purchase in that category
  • Four online BNPL service providers in Canada have a GMV of more than $1 billion

Prospects for Online BNPL in Canada - 2024 provides a deep dive into the Canadian online BNPL market, examining key players, market segments and trends, the supply structure, delivery mechanisms, the competitive environment, regulatory developments, and the implications for both consumers and businesses. The central aim of this report is to provide actionable insights into the current state of the online BNPL market in Canada and the most important factors shaping its future trajectory. The forecast horizon is the five year period to 2028, with 2023 as the base year.

Drawing on survey research from more than 2,000 Canadian consumers, Prospects for Online BNPL in Canada - 2024 is a critical strategic resource for payment professionals active in the BNPL market, providing in-depth insights and forecasts to facilitate effective strategic planning, competitive positioning and product development in this highly dynamic marketplace.

Methodology:

  • Online research
  • Executive interviews
  • Conferences and seminars
  • Consumer Research: Findings from our primary market research among 2,000 adult Canadian consumers
  • Analysis and insight, based on 30+ years of advising clients in the international payments market

Table of Contents


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
  • Overview
  • Objectives of the Study
BNPL IN A GLOBAL CONTEXT
  • The Evolution of BNPL
  • The Global Market for BNPL Services
THE CANADIAN MARKET FOR ONLINE BNPL SERVICES
  • Online Shopping in Canada
  • Awareness and Usage of Online BNPL Services
  • Demand for Online BNPL Services in Canada
  • Online BNPL Expenditure by Category
  • BNPL Expenditure by Region in Canada
CHARACTERISTICS OF ONLINE BNPL USERS
  • Usage of Online BNPL by Generational Segment
  • Usage of Online BNPL by Household Income Group
  • User Perceptions of BNPL
  • Future Usage Intent
  • Payment Methods for Online BNPL Services
SUPPLY STRUCTURE AND DELIVERY MECHANISMS
  • Supply Structure by Type of Provider
  • Delivery Mechanisms
THE COMPETITIVE ENVIRONMENT
  • Awareness of Online BNPL Service Offerings
  • Usage of Online BNPL Service Offerings
  • Market Share of Major Suppliers
  • The Dynamics of BNPL Market Competition
FUTURE DIRECTIONS
  • Competition and innovation
  • Regulation
  • Consumer adoption
  • Industry profitability and consolidation
APPENDIX A
  • Competitor Profiles of Major Fintech BNPL Service Providers Operating in Canada
  • Affirm
  • Afterpay
  • Flexiti
  • Klarna
  • Sezzle
  • Uplift
APPENDIX B
  • Research Methodology
  • List of Abbreviations
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Value of Global BNPL Expenditure (2019 - 2028)
Figure 2: Forecast Value of Online Purchases in Canada (2015-2028)
Figure 3: Online BNPL Awareness by Generational Segment (2022 and 2023)
Figure 4: Awareness and Usage of Online BNPL Services Among Online Shoppers
Figure 5: Forecast Value and Volume of Online BNPL Expenditure in Canada (2019 - 2028)
Figure 6: Online BNPL Expenditure in Canada by Category (2023)
Figure 7: Incidence of Online Shopping and BNPL Purchases by Category in Canada (2023)
Figure 8: Intensity of BNPL Usage Across BNPL User Shopping Categories
Figure 9: BNPL Expenditure by Region in Canada (2023)
Figure 10: Regional BNPL Indicators
Figure 11: Distribution of Online BNPL Users vs Online Shoppers by Generational Segment
Figure 12: Proportion of Online Shoppers in each Generational Segment that have used BNPL (P12M) (2021-2023)
Figure 13: BNPL Expenditure by Generational Segment
Figure 14: Income Distribution of Online BNPL Users vs Online Shoppers
Figure 15: Reasons for Using Online BNPL
Figure 16: The Disadvantages of Online BNPL
Figure 17: User Behaviour with Online BNPL
Figure 18: Online BNPL Usage Intent Among Online Shoppers by Generational Segment (N12M)
Figure 19: Online BNPL Usage Intent by Online Shoppers Aware of Online BNPL (N12M)
Figure 20: Payment Methods used for Online BNPL Services
Figure 21: BNPL Expenditure by Type of BNPL Service Provider
Figure 22: Online BNPL Delivery Process (Swim Lane Diagram)
Figure 23: Awareness of Online BNPL Service Providers Among Online Shoppers
Figure 24: Brand Awareness of Online BNPL by Generational Segment
Figure 25: Usage of Online BNPL Service Providers (P12M)
Figure 26: Brand Conversion Ratios of Online BNPL Service Providers
Figure 27: Market Share by BNPL Provider (2023)

LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: BNPL Instalment Plan Options After Purchase
Table 2: Key Financial Metrics of Affirm, Klarna and Sezzle
Table 3: Components of BNPL Revenue: Affirm, Klarna and Sezzle

Executive Summary

Canadian BNPL expenditure on online purchases amounted to $12.3 billion (CAD) in 2023, representing 16.2% of online sales and 1.6% of retail sales. Growth in BNPL GMV for e-commerce purchases in Canada is expected to exceed 30% p.a. (CAGR) over the period 2023 to 2028. By 2028, Canadian online BNPL will account for 4.1% of global online GMV.

“Canada has been late to adopt online BNPL services relative to our US and European counterparts. However, since 2019 growth has been much higher than in those jurisdictions, spurred on by the e-commerce explosion during the COVID pandemic and financial pressure on households, which made deferred interest-free payments for online purchases an attractive proposition for many consumers.”

More than 70% of all online BNPL users in Canada were from the Gen Z and Millennial generational segments in 2023, according to the report, but adoption in the older segments is increasing suggesting significant headroom for growth across all segments.

“One of the concerns raised about BNPL services is that it is said to target low-income households. This research shows that this is definitely not the case in Canada. Online shoppers from households with incomes of less than $50k are far less likely to use online BNPL services than those in higher income households.”

Competition in the online BNPL space in Canada is intense, with most of the large global fintech BNPL service providers having entered the Canadian market in the past few years. Major credit card issuers in Canada have also started offering online BNPL services and have captured a significant share of the market in a relatively short time span, according to the report. The Canadian Tire Triangle Card BNPL offering has gained the most traction in Canada.

“Credit card issuers were concerned, for good reason, that the fintech BNPL players would erode their revenue base. Interestingly, the majority of online BNPL users pay their instalments using a credit card.”

The report examines the financial metrics of three key players in the fintech BNPL space and highlights some of the challenges facing the industry in terms of profitability, credit losses and funding costs. It goes on to predict that BNPL product innovation will play an important role in shaping the future of online BNPL in Canada and, while Canadian regulatory authorities have adopted a ‘wait and see’ approach, a strong regulatory response could have a dampening impact on the market.

Companies Mentioned

  • Affirm
  • Afterpay
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple
  • Block
  • BMO
  • BRIM Financial 
  • Canadian Tire
  • Celerant Technology
  • CIBC
  • CURO Group Holdings
  • FCAC
  • Flexiti
  • Google
  • Klarna
  • MasterCard
  • MBNA
  • Miller Thomson LLP
  • Norton Rose Fullbright
  • Paybright
  • PayPal
  • Questrade
  • RBC
  • Scotiabank
  • Sezzle
  • Splitit
  • Stripe
  • TD Bank
  • Upgrade
  • Uplift
  • Visa
  • Walmart
  • Zip